Search blog.co.uk

Archives for: October 2007

GOETTERDAEMMERUNG, ROH Covent Garden, 24 November 2007

by leonora @ 25/10/07 - 18:37:13

GOETTERDAEMMERUNG, ROH Covent Garden, 24 October 2007

CAST

First Norn........................Catherine Wyn-Rogers
Second Norn....................Yvonne Howard
Third Norn.......................Marina Poplavskaya
Siegfried.........................John Treleaven
Brunnhilde.......................Lisa Gasteen
Gunther..........................Peter Coleman-Wright
Hagen............................James Moellenhoff
Gutrune..........................Emily Magee
Waltraute......................  Mihoko Fujimura
Alberich..........................Peter Sidhom
Woglinde.........................Sarah Fox
Wellgunde.......................Heather Shipp
Flosshilde........................Sarah Castle

Chorus and Orchestra of the Royal Opera House
Chorus Master.................Renato Balsadonna
Concert Master................Vasko Vassilev

Conductor......................Antonio Pappano

Director..........................Keith Warner
Set Designs.....................Stefanos Lazaridis

Musically and dramatically, this has been a wonderful RING. I've already
praised Pappano's conducting to the skies, and if anything this was even
better than the preceding evenings. He gives detailed attention to every
nuance of orchestral shading - I espcially noticed details like the brass shining
out when Siegfried and Brunnhilde swear their oaths in Act II. Siegfried's
Funeral March was truly heroic, and poignant, and compensated for the fact
he doesn't GET a Funeral March on the stage, he gets up and wanders slowly
off - I imagine it's meant to represent a ghost disappearing into the mists, but
it would have been a bit disappointing had the music not compensated for the
deficiencies of the staging.
twilight12367

John Treleavan was in much better voice that he was in SIEGFRIED, and
managed quite a creditable performance. Lisa Gasteen had recovered from her
indisposition, and was in radiant voice - this is probably an even more testing
role than the WALKUEURE Brunnhilde, as she develops so many facets of her
character - she starts as a young girl in love, then she is a betrayed (and
brutalised) wife, then an avenging fury and finally, when all this is over, she
has attained wisdom and resignation. Gasteen rose magnificently to the
challenge, with steely, ringing tones for the confrontation in Act II, and
mellow in the Immolation scene - I remember when I saw her last year, her
sensitive enunciation of 'Ruhe, ruhe, du Gott' brought tears to my eyes, and it
did again yesterday evening. Really a great and believable Brunnhilde.
lisagasteenKenton372

Another splendid performance was given by the Waltraute, Mihoko Fujimura.
Not only a lovely mezzo voice, but a really intelligent, sensitive portrayal of
the role.

The Hagen was James Moellenhoff. (Apparently it was to have been Kurt Rydl -
it would probably have been too much to expect Tomlinson to sing Wotan
AND Hagen). I liked the quality of stillness he had, which contrasted well with
Gunther (Peter Coleman-Wright) and Gutrune (Emily Magee), who were
portrayed as very restless, nervy and fidgety. This suits the character of
Gunther very well, of course, emphasising his insecurity. Hagen then remains
on the stage during Waltraute's narration (though the audience forgets about
him, as Mikoko Fujimura's performance is so gripping), and the scene that
follows - he does nothing until the very end, when Siegfried announces that
he intends to place his sword between himself and Brunnhilde - then Hagen
rises and lifts his chair in a gesture of triumph. He had the right quality of
grimness, suddenly relaxing into sardonic humour, in the Summoning of the
Vassals.
roh-twilight
I will say a few words about the staging - one thing I particularly disliked was
the fact that when Siegfried comes back disguised as Gunther - well, he is
there wearing the Rubik Cube, sorry Tarnhelm, but - SO IS GUNTHER. This is
ridiculous, and makes nonsense of the whole scene, the point of which is that
IT ISN'T GUNTHER. The other problem is that Brunnhilde has a horse's skull -
remember the Valkyries all had horses' skulls? - which she gives to Siegfried
(Fuer den Ring nimm nun auch mein Ross), which he then hands to Hagen
when he arrives in the Gibichung's Hall.......I still do not see what the point of
this is. (Never mind, watch Pappano conducting instead!!)
However, there were aspects of the staging I liked - in the Immolation Scene,
the statues of the Gods (which were also present on the stage during the
wedding scene in Act II) are brought in to form part of the funeral pyre and
are consumed in the general conflagration. The backdrop is a cloth covered
with mathematical symbols and a swirling galaxy, which is very effective.

A triumph for Antonio Pappano.
Dr. Jane Susanna ENNIS
http://members.fortunecity.co.uk/leonora/wagner.html


 
 

SIEGFRIED, ROH Covent Garden, 21 October 2007

by leonora @ 22/10/07 - 09:27:59
  1. beardsleysiegfried


    SIEGFRIED, ROH Covent Garden, 21 October 2007

    Cast:
    Mime...........Gerhard Siegel
    Siegfried..................Jon Trevleaven
    Wanderer...................John Tomlinson
    Fafner....................Philip Ens
    Woodbird..................Ailish Tynan
    Erda..................... Jane Henschel
    Brunnhilde................Irene Theorin

    Orchestra of the Royal Opera House
    Conductor................Antonio Pappano

    Director.................Keith Warner
    Set Designs..................tefanos Laziridis

    Yet again, I start by praising Antonio Pappano and the orchestra, the beautiful
    subtlety of the Forest Murmurs movement, and especially the serene beauty
    of the orchestral passage as Siegfried emerges onto the mountain-top - I
    always feel when I hear this that I don't want him to start singing and break
    the spell, and never more so than last night!
    John Tomlinson was perhaps not in quite as good voice as he had been in DIE
    WALKUERE, but this suits the characterisation of the weary Wanderer, who is
    still able - just - to frighten Mime with his spear, but of course has no effect
    on Siegfried. I especially liked the scene with Alberich (Peter Sidhom), as the
    contrast between them was so well conveyed, Tomlinson convincing in
    Wotan's declaration of his wish to stand aside and let the younger generation
    take over, Sidhom conveying the fact that Alberich HAS NOT CHANGED AT
    ALL, the venom in his voice says it all!
    I could hardly hear the Mime (Gerhard Siegel) most of the time- and I
    gathered that many people in the audience had a similar problem. Trawling
    back through my archives, I discover that I had the same problem two years
    ago! So I am wondering if it's part of the characterisation - Pappano is usually
    very sensitive to the needs of the singers, and never lets them be
    overwhelmed by the orchestra. The situation did improve during Act II, and I
    was amused by the metamorphosis into the rat when Mime reveals his evil
    intentions towards Siegfried.
    Jon Treleaven was unfortunately unable to cope with the demands of the role -
    he managed the Forging Scene quite creditably, but in the final scene he
    was visibly, and audibly, exhausted, hardly managing to sing in tune. Everyone
    applauded him for effort, anyway, because he did do his best.
    Irene Theorin stood in for Lisa Gasteen and was a sympathetic young
    Brunnhilde - she probably won't be able to cope with the
    GOETTERDAEMMERUNG Brunnhilde, so if Gasteen has not recovered, we must
    hope that Susan Bullock takes over again.
    The staging - there are some aspects I like, and some I can do without.....I
    actually like the crashed plane round which Mime and Siegfried have made
    their home, especially when the Wanderer unexpectedly clambers out of the
    cockpit. I was less impressed with the Forest, which looked rather like Santa's
    grotto, especially with the stuffed animals. The final few moments of Act II
    served to emphasise Siegfried's extreme youth and silliness...he's about to run
    off after the Woodbird, and she (played by a young woman dressed in white)
    has to point at his sword to remind him to go back for it, THEN to remind him
    to go back for the Tarnhelm (silly Rubik's Cube - I'm STILL not happy with
    that!) and the Ring.
    A couple of days' break, then on Wednesday it is GOETTERDAEMMERUNG.

DIE WALKUERE, Rpyal Opera House, 19 October 2007

by leonora @ 21/10/07 - 00:28:45

DIE WALKUERE, Royal Opera House, Covent Garden, 19 October 2007

Cast
Siegmund.................................Placido Domingo
Sieglinde..................................Eva-Maria Westbroek
Hunding...................................Stephen Milling
Wotan.....................................John Tomlinson
Brunnhilde................................Susan Bullock
Fricka......................................Rosalind Plowright

Valkyries
Gerhilde.................Geraldine McGreevy
Ortlinde...................................Elaine McKrill
Waltraute................................Claire Powell
Schwertleite............................Rebecca de Pont Davies
Helmwige.................................Irene Theorin
Siegrune................................. Sarah Castle
Grimgerde................................Clare Shearer
Rossweise................................Elizabeth Sikora

Orchestra of the Royal Opera House
Concert Master........................Vasko Vassilev

Conductor..............................Antonio Pappano

Director..................................Keith Warner
Set Designs............................Stefanos Lazaridis

You were probably expecting to see the name of Lisa Gasteen as Brunnhilde in
the cast list, but she had to withdraw because of ill-health - fortunately
Susan Bullock was able to take over at very short notice, and was a more
than adequate replacement.

But I'll start at the beginning - during the first few minutes, the orchestra
sounded slightly 'muffled', the brass not having quite the piercing quality one
hopes for, but this soon improved, and the 'chamber music' quality of much of
the first act (the motifs that characterise the Volsungs and the growing
attraction between Siegmund and Sieglinde) was very sensitively played under Pappano's skilful conducting - in fact at some points I shut my eyes so that I could listen to the music in a more focussed way, it was so exquisite!

Domingo's Siegmund has lost none of its qualities over the years - his German is rotten, but who cares! He produced a really heroic ring with 'Waelse, Waelse, wo ist dein Schwert!', and great tenderness in 'Winterstuerme' - but
the greatest moments were reserved for the Todesverkuendigung, the quite
resolution with which he replies to Brunnhilde's announcement was amazing.
The music rises to a pitch of almost unbearable tension in the orchestra as
Siegmund asks, 'Begleitet den Bruder die braeutliche Schwester? Umfaengt
Siegmund Sieglinde dort?' and then the tension is broken with Brunnhilde's
quiet reply - delivered with calm dignity by Susan Bullock - she is an
experienced Brunnhilde, although this is the first time she has sung the role at Covent Garden. She has a clear voice with soaring top notes (I have heard
her before as Desdemona and as Isolde). I also liked the passionate Sieglinde
of Eva-Maria Westbroek.
roh-walkure-3roh-walkure-4

John Tomlinson just IS Wotan!!! It's forty years since I first saw the RING, but
Wotan's Farewell still has me in tears, as it did yesterday. Wotan runs the
whole gamut of emotions in this opera, from hope - almost elation - to
despair, and this is one of the best and most convincing performances I've
seen in recent years. At the opening of Act II, he waves his spear about in
triumph, as he obviously thinks he has found the solution to his problem - of
course Fricka (Rosalind Plowright) disabuses him of this notion. When she
finally gets his promise, he kneels to kiss her hand, and she pats him on the
shoulder, as if to thank him. When I saw this production last year, with Terfel
as Wotan, he accepted her embrace - but Tomlinson flinched away from her,
which is perhaps more logical.
 
roh-walkureroh-walkure-2

Something else which I found interesting - when
he leaves Brunnhilde and storms off in anger, the stage directions AND THE
MUSIC indicate that he should 'stride furiously away', but in fact he walked
very slowly and hesitantly off, while Brunnhilde follows him with his spear,
which he has forgotten - so, although this seems to be acting against the
music, it works as a way of showing Wotan's distress. Similarly at the end of
Act II, rather than storming off in pursuit of Brunnhilde, he returns and kneels
by the side of the dead Siegmund, wringing his hands in despair.

The staging has some attractive moments; for instance, when Spring bursts
into Hunding's hut, this in indicated by a burst of light, and a shower of rose
petals falling from the roof - Sieglinde lifts her face to receive them. On the
other hand, I could really do without the horses' skulls that the Valkyries
carry - I haven't yet met one member of the audience who DOES like this, and
I cannot understand what the point is - unless it's just to get a cheap laugh.
But it has to be said that at the crucial moments the director and stage
designer forget about the gimmicks and just let the cast sing and the
orchestra play - or perhaps it's just that the scene between Wotan and
Brunnhilde in Act III was so gripping that the audience forgot about the
production gimmicks.

Tomorrow is SIEGFRIED.
Dr. Jane Susanna ENNIS

http://members.fortunecity.co.uk/leonora/wagner.html

DAS RHEINGOLD, Royal Opera House, October 17 2007

by leonora @ 18/10/07 - 16:19:02

DAS RHEINGOLD, Royal Opera House, 17 October 2007

Cast:

Woglinde...................................Sarah Fox
Wellgunde...............Heather Shipp
Flosshilde ......................Sarah Castle
Alberich.................................... Peter Sidhom
Wotan......................................John Tomlinson
Fricka.......................................Rosalind Plowright
Freia........................................ Emily Magee
Fasolt.......................................Franz-Josef Selig
Fafner.......................................Philip Ens
Froh.........................................Will Hartmann
Donner..................................... Peter Coleman-Wright
Loge.........................................Philip Langridge
Mime.........................................Gerhard Siegel
Erda.........................................Jane Henschel 

Orchestra of the Royal Opera House
Concert Master Vassko Vassilev

Conductor...................................Antonio Pappano

Director......................................Keith Warner
Set Designs..................................Stefanos Lazaridis

I hope the excellence of this performance is a good omen for the rest of the
RING! Pappano drew such burnished tones from the orchestra, right from that magical, mysterious beginning - and I liked the fact that there wasn't the
usual business of the conductor coming on beforehand to be applauded, it
creates a much better atmosphere if the sound seems to emerge from
nowhere. The orchestral balance was ideal, and Pappano takes it at a tempo
that seems exactly appropriate and also gives due emphasis to the passages
for solo instruments at crucial moments. Pappano is also very sensitive to the needs of the singers.
Antonio_Pappano
I would single out for special praise John Tomlinson's Wotan and Philip
Langridge's Loge. Tomlinson's deep sonorous voice is of course well-known and highly praised, but he is also a gifted actor and gave a very subtle
characterisation of  Wotan as a god with very human failings! Especially, of
course, that of greed and lust for power, and he is beginning to intuit that this
is going to be his undoing, even as he waves the sword around before the
entry into Walhall. 
roh-rheingold

Loge, of course, will have nothing to do with any of this.
the particular qualities of Langridge's tenor voice are ideal for this role (who is actually my favourite character in the RING!) . There are nice touches of
comic genius, such as the fact that when Donner summons the thunder, the
other gods stand apathetically around while Loge sits under an outsize
umbrella - eliciting laughter from the audience, as of course it's yet another
way in which Loge undercuts the pretensions of the others.
Peter Sidhom as Alberich seemed to start off tentatively, but this was
obviously part of the characterisation, as he gained in power - and of course
malevolence - in the Nibelheim scene. This is the point at which I must start
to describe the production - Nibelheim is, among other things, a laboratory in
which monstrous experiments on humans and animals are being perpetrated, there is a mutilated skeleton on a hospital trolley, and Loge throws some of
the body parts away - later, after Alberich has been captured by Wotan and
Loge, Mime throws some more body parts away. (An interesting idea, BUT I
started to wonder if it wasn't a bit too 'busy').The actual gold which Alberich
has been amassing is barely visible, as it is all packed into suitcases, which
Mime has to carry around, and which are too heavy for him.
The Tarnhelm is - an outsize Rubik Cube, which glitters in certain lights
 
roh-rheingold-2

- yes,
Ok, but the novelty will have worn off by GOETTERDAEMMERUNG (I've seen
this production before!) One thing I did like, though, was that when Alberich is tricked into turning himself into a toad - a little toad with a MINI-Rubik Cube
on its head hops across the stage!
Mime is sung by Gerhard Siegel, who emphasised very well the contrast
between the Nibelung brothers - Mime lacks the tragic grandeur that makes
Alberich a distant cousin of Milton's Satan - something that was very apparent when he cursed the Ring - which of course is now on Wotan's finger, and
Alberich actually takes Wotan's hand when he curses the Ring - I haven't seen it played like this before.

I'll return to the beginning now - the Rheinmaidens are naked right at the
start, but as soon as Alberich appears they hurriedly scramble into some
clothes (probably not before he's had a good stare, though, as they don't see
him at first). 
1Rheingold

 One thing I particular liked about the staging was that the
projections of green wavy lines that indicated the Rhine gradually change into  a spinning globe with Mercator projections - the globe becomes smaller and  smaller as the Valhalla scene approaches, and Valhalla is shown as the interior  of a rather grand mansion with a black marble fireplace and matching black  furniture.
roh-rheingold-3
 
Fricka and Freia were wearing very elegant Edwardian tea-gowns.
roh-rheingold-4

Rosalind Plowright was very good as Fricka, her warm mezzo tones contrasting  well with the soprano of Emily Magee - who sang well but her characterisation  was a bit lack-lustre. I liked the fact the she seemed to tentatively respond  to Fasolt's genuine affection for her. The giants were sung by Philip Ens and
Franz-Josef Selig.

***********
Dr. Jane Susanna ENNIS
http://members.fortunecity.co.uk/leonora/ring1.html


 
 

Footer

The content of this website belongs to a private person, blog.co.uk is not responsible for the content of this website.